I booked my ticket and hotel room for the Rally to Restore Sanity the day it was announced. There were some clues of it happening on Reddit once the DonorsChoose campaign kicked off (where Colbert sent a personal message to Reddit when the donation total blew past $100k in 24 hours), so I was prepared when it was announced. Once it was announced, however, it was pretty obvious that nobody really knew what this rally would actually accomplish. Was it just to talk about how the level of political discourse had gotten completely out of hand? Was it to mock Glenn Beck's 8/28 rally? Was it to drive youth turnout to the 2010 midterm elections? Or was it just an opportunity for fans of The Daily Show to meet up?

The truth is a blend of all of those, with different ratios depending on who you talk to. The event itself was rife with comedy and music. The signs and costumes were hilarious and well executed demonstrations of apathy and discontent with the process. The people themselves were extremely nice and polite. It was positive, not negative. It was nationalist, not political. And even if Stewart started his rally wrap-up speech with a rhetorical question of "what exactly was this?", the message was clear, as it was when the event was announced: "take it down a notch, for America".

Most of all, it was a wonderful vacation away from the political rhetoric that tends to get ratcheted up to its most extreme in the days before an election.

What should not be doubted is the impact of the event. The event planners filed a permit for 60,000 people; they got port-a-potties for 150,000. But every estimate has put the number way higher. MTV, Comedy Central's owner, claimed over 250k. National Park Service reportedly and unofficially estimated over 200k. And CBS/AirPhotosLive estimated 215k (of note, AirPhotosLive did an estimate on Glenn Beck's Restoring Honor rally, and pegged that number at 87k ± 9k). And this does not include the thousands of satellite rallies held across the United States and in countries all over the world, as well as all the people who watched it on Comedy Central, on C-SPAN, or watched a stream online. They were clearly not prepared for the sheer size of the crowd. A number of times during the event, especially during the brief and minor technical difficulties, there was a chant of "Louder! Louder!" that swelled from the back and sides of the crowd. The screens and sound systems were not placed far back for many attendees. Even the Mythbusters' appearance showed that it took over 50 seconds for a wave to make it from the front to the back. This event was monstrous in scale.

Stewart's impassioned speech at the end really hit home for me. Juan Williams is not a racist, Rick Sanchez is not a bigot, Muslims are not terrorists, and conflating these makes it harder to tell who's actually a racist/bigot/terrorist. The economic disaster and our wars have made these difficult times, but not the catastrophic end of days that members of the media so often claim. Liberals, conservatives, Democrats, Republicans, the loudest big government progressives, the most staunch of the Tea Partiers, and everyone in between make compromises every day to make society function properly, except in Washington DC and except in the political media.

The news media has largely failed at covering the event. They were there, sure, but they spent most of their time decrying the rallygoers as hipsters and potheads. They also downplayed the effect of those that went by saying those would be people who were already going to vote. Only a couple analysts seemed to understand that it wasn't about the left vs the right, or about the Tea Party vs Progressives, but that it was about the process vs the wants of the people.

It was sobering and illuminating to learn just how many like minded people are out there. Hopefully the politicians and people in the media get the hint, and dial down some of this rhetoric that only perpetuates the problems instead of working to fix them.

P.S. I wrote and published this on a plane. The future? Still awesome.

, ,    Tags

We've all got our thoughts on what the Jesus Tablet will be, so here are my guesses. I fully expect to be completely wrong on all of this, as many of these answers are completely blind shots and that Apple will blow my expectations out of the water.


  • 8"-10" touch screen, running at 1280x720
  • Very thin; less than 1/2" thick (the iPhone 3GS is 0.48" thick)
  • About 1lb heavy, light enough to hold in one hand
  • 8 hours of battery life
  • 32 or 64 GB SSD
  • WiFi
  • 3G over GSM, and Apple's US 3G partner will continue to be AT&T
  • There will be some way to pair your Tablet cell connection with your iPhone's cell connection; either with an official announcement of AT&T tethering, or by adding your Tablet to the 3G account
  • Front-mounted camera
  • Some kind of collapsible stand in the frame, so the device can sit on a table


  • Multi-touch on the display, exactly like the iPhone
  • Multi-touch on the back of the device, similar to the surface of the Magic Mouse
  • Photos and video via front-mounted camera
  • Audio via front-mounted microphone and speakers, wired headphones, or Bluetooth
  • Dock connector
  • Expanded voice recognition
  • Software keyboard, no Bluetooth keyboards available


  • It will run the iPhone OS 4.0; or rather, the iPhone OS will become a "Mobile OS X", consisting of the heavyweight Tablet and the smaller iPhone.
  • It will allow multiple apps to run at the same time, with some UI for viewing multiple apps alongside each other. This may not be possible on the iPhone.
  • It meant to replace a full PC for most common day-to-day needs
  • iPhone applications will not run "automatically", but will need to be resubmitted through the App Store approval process. Most applications will run without much modifications. Icons will need to be higher resolution.
  • A system-wide Dock for documents, applications, and small widgets will be onscreen at all times
  • The home screen will be significantly revamped, and renamed to the Dashboard. App icons, web clippings, and widgets will be freely arrangeable.
  • Handwriting recognition will be available for text input, with an optional stylus, or with a gesture such as two closed fingers drawing as if you had a pen.
  • Some gestures will be used on the back of the device, such as scrolling and zooming.


  • Standard kind of iPod and Internet communications apps the iPhone OS comes with. iTunes video, iTunes LP content, Maps, and Safari web content will look phenomenal.
  • Sketchbook, an unlimited workspace to sketch and write notes, with collaboration features.
  • iWork, a full port of the iWork application suite, tied to the Internet (and expansion of the iWork.com web application), with collaboration features.
  • iChat, a port of the Mac app, with a heavy emphasis on video conferencing


  • The SDK will be available immediately, with a simulator.
  • There will be an emphasis on application interoperability.
  • Applications will be able to register plugins with view controllers and UTIs. When an application wants to expose an object (say, an image) to other apps, it will look for app plugins which respond to the "public.image" UTI, load one which matches the UTI, and present the view without leaving the application.
  • Applications will be able to expose services, similar to how they work on Mac OS X. Services will be integrated into the voice control system.


  • 32 GB model will be available for $899
  • 64 GB model will be available for $999
  • Available in US in March, major countries by summer
  • There will not be a WiFi-only model at launch.

Other Predictions

  • Updated MacBook Pros and MacBook Airs, with the mobile Core i5 "Arrandale" processors from Intel.
  • There will be no mention of Verizon
  • There will be no updates to the iPod or the Apple TV
  • There will be no announcements of the iPhone 4G

I totally agree with Chris on this one. We are only now getting to the point where users are being exposed to significantly more complex web applications. Atwood is arguing against innovation in that space; I say embrace it.